Home » The thatch dilution delusion

thatch dilution delusion
thatch builds up quickly on unhealthy greens

The thatch dilution delusion

Thatch dilution is one of the big claims often made for the efficacy of sand top-dressing, but what does that mean?

The thinking here is that due to the continuing production of thatch by the grass plants, in order to ensure that our rootzone (top-soil) continues to build up as a uniform, homogenous medium, we need to add a layer of sand for the organic material to mix with from time to time.

This idea, although well intentioned in every case, is dangerously inaccurate in terms of soil science and invariably leads to poor bowls green performance caused by thick, matted thatch.

There are two mistakes in this thought process:

  • Mistake number 1: That thatch is the same as soil Organic Matter
  • Mistake number 2: That soil Organic Matter is the same as the non-sand component of topsoils/rootzones.

Organic MatterThe 3 stages of Organic Matter in Soil

You will recall from earlier articles that soil Organic Matter comes in three main forms:

  1. Living organisms such as plants, worms, microbes and bowlers 🙂
  2. Recently deposited/fresh Organic Material, such as dead grass roots, stolons, shoots, animal droppings etc, that has still to be processed by the soil organisms and microbes. Thatch is in this category.
  3. Stable Organic Matter that has been fully recycled/decomposed and is now Humus.

Thatch and Mat

Mixing sand with humus to create a nicely balanced, homogenous topsoil (not necessarily a good idea as a rootzone for sportsturf) is actually a reasonable idea, but mixing sand with un-decomposed thatch is never a good idea and will result in a thick, dense, impenetrable mat on top of the green. When thatch becomes matted like this, it can’t be broken down by the soil organisms and simply gets thicker, denser and more troublesome as time goes on.

Mineral and Organic

In an earlier article I described the make up of rootzones for bowls greens and you might recall that there are various fractions within the soil which are defined mainly by their particle size.

It is essential to have around 10% fines by weight (mostly clay and silt) within the mineral component of the rootzone to help provide water and nutrient holding capacity.

More on the mineral component of rootzones and Particle Size Distribution here

The thatch dilution delusion.

The thatch dilution theory confuses these fines with Organic Matter and assumes that sand plus thatch equals a good rootzone; it doesn’t. Organic Matter is a critical component of a lively, healthy rootzone, but it can’t replace the fines such as silt and clay. In any case, un-decomposed thatch is not Organic Matter, but organic Material awaiting processing by the soil life and microlife.

More on Organic Matter here

Questions, contributions and examples welcome in the comments below:

6 comments

  1. terry beer says:

    Hi John we have used our verti cutter to rake out thatch, we stopped after after 5 times going over the whole of the bowling green.
    This seems to have improved the green pace but it didn’t take out the blackened moss.
    What can i do to get rid of this moss which we treated with iron sulphate

    • John Quinn says:

      Hi Terry

      Good to hear from you.

      The verti-cutter blades are designed for cutting through lateral growth and as such won’t be well suited to removing dead moss. You might want to try your scarifier if you have one, or a wire rake if you don’t. Take it easy though.

      John

  2. St. Paul's Bowling Club says:

    Hi John, following core sampling we have up to two inches of thatch in the wetter area of our green, the thatch is sour smelling and moss is more of a problem there as well. We were told that the soil registered as acidic. To try to tackle this we have scarified four times since April, have fertilised four times, early season with granular Spring/Summer feed and last two with liquid feed. We plan to hollow tine, deep scarify, overseed, top dress, deep aerate (4-5 inch chisel tines) and apply Calcifert starting late September (after season ends) through into October. We want to help reduce the thatch thickness, correct the acidity and promote healthy grass growth, is what we plan likely to help, are we missing anything, what mix of top dress should we use (we can get 70:30 thru to 50:50) and do you know of anyone in the East Lancs area who will visit greens and give truly independent advice, paid for of course?
    Thanks Peter

    • John Quinn says:

      Hi Peter
      The acidity will be part and parcel of the thatch and the associated compaction and anaerobic conditions. When you deal with the thatch and compaction, the soil pH will stabilise quite quickly.

      Regarding the correct program, you should probably leave out the top dressing and switch from a standard scarifier to something like the Graden GS04 after hollow tining at 2″ centres with jumbo (5/8″) tines. This will remove around 20% of the green surface (thatch), introduce a huge volume of air and get your microbes working on the thatch that remains. You might well have to repeat this next year.

      Here’s my suggestion (you’ll have to decide if it suits your current conditions):

      Apply Ferromex or double dose of lawn sand (for moss) 14 days before the following:
      Hollow tining (5/8″ tines) at 2″ centres
      Graden (or HD Sisis) over the top of the cores
      Clean up debris, brush and clean up cut with mower (>6mm)
      Carbohydrate application in form of Molturf (molasses), Seaweed Meal or Liquid (Kelpac or similar)
      Autumn fertiliser (K recharge or similar)
      No top dressing.
      If your green also has Localised Dry Patch, it would be wise to apply a granular wetting agent as well.
      Twice monthly deep slit tining (Sisis Autoslit or similar) October to March.
      Twice monthly cut (after slitting and when conditions allow) at 7 or 8mm
      Further Carbohydrate applications monthly as above during winter.
      Spot treatment of disease outbreaks with curative fungicide: no blanket or preventative treatments if at all possible.

      Some guidance on assessing the soil and turf conditions here

      Regarding local advice, I don’t know anyone in your area who would give you the right advice. The majority of advisers will tell you to throw lots of sand on your green and in most cases this is detrimental to green condition.

      If you can let me know a bit more about your findings when you do soil profiles, I can advise further.

      Regards

      John

  3. Alan Lindsay says:

    There is a great product for helping the problem called Thatcheater and what you are doing is adding good bugs to your soil that eat thatch but not the roots of your fine grasses

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.